Spirit Week Would You Rather: 20 Classroom Questions

Start a spirit week conversation with 20 original would-you-rather questions, pair-discussion ideas, and an editable question pack.

Questions
20 in four groups
Format
Conversation, not a vote
Included
Editable question pack

Use the questions as a conversation starter

These 20 original spirit week would-you-rather questions invite students to choose between two imagined options and explain a reason. They can be a short opening discussion, a pair conversation or a writing starter. Students do not need a themed outfit or supplies from home.

This is a suggested classroom activity, not a tested assessment or a school theme ballot. There are no correct answers. Choosing an idea in conversation does not mean the school will schedule it, or that the student must take part in a later performance.

Choose a few questions that fit the class. Read both options clearly, pause, and let students think before inviting a response. Keep the questions about ideas and activities rather than classmates’ appearances, family spending or who participated in the week.

  • Select three to five questions rather than rushing through the whole list.
  • Decide whether responses will be spoken, drawn, written or optional listening.
  • Explain that “both,” “neither” and “pass” are acceptable responses.
  • Use the class’s familiar turn-taking routine.

A reader copy is enough. The paper cards in the illustrative photograph are optional; you can read straight from the list or use the downloadable text pack.

20 spirit week would-you-rather questions

Each group contains five questions. Start with a familiar choice, then invite a reason if the student wants to give one. The follow-up can be as simple as “What makes that option interesting to you?”

Imagine a theme

  1. Would you rather invent a day based on one color or one pattern?

  2. Would you rather imagine a hat shaped like a cloud or socks patterned with tiny stars?

  3. Would you rather plan a storybook theme or an outer-space theme?

  4. Would you rather design a tiny spirit-day detail or a giant paper classroom decoration?

  5. Would you rather create a theme with a funny name or a surprising drawing?

These are imagined choices, not requests to buy or wear anything. Browse the theme collection if the class wants more examples.

Make something together

  1. Would you rather draw one piece of a class mural or help arrange the finished pieces?

  2. Would you rather make a paper team emblem or write a short team motto?

  3. Would you rather decorate a paper book spine or a paper pennant?

  4. Would you rather choose two colors for a display or two shapes for its border?

  5. Would you rather explain your design with a picture or a few sentences?

The paper display designs offer a separate activity if staff decide to turn an idea into a project.

Choose a classroom game

  1. Would you rather solve a written riddle or guess a silent gesture?

  2. Would you rather get one extra clue or another minute to think?

  3. Would you rather invent a clue or help test whether it makes sense?

  4. Would you rather guess an imaginary object or an imaginary classroom action?

  5. Would you rather try a game in pairs or with a small group?

These questions connect to the riddle pack and charades prompts. A conversational choice does not commit someone to performing.

Share an idea

  1. Would you rather suggest a new theme aloud or write it on a card?

  2. Would you rather explain an idea with a short story or a labeled drawing?

  3. Would you rather ask a question about tomorrow’s theme or give one simple example?

  4. Would you rather help draft a reminder or check that its dates match the schedule?

  5. Would you rather thank a helper with a short note or a small drawing?

The writing prompts and thank-you starters can extend a discussion when the teacher chooses.

Try a short pair-discussion routine

For a suggested eight-minute slot, use two minutes to explain and model one question, four minutes for pairs to discuss two selected questions, and two minutes for optional sharing. Adjust the number of questions and time to the class; the outline does not guarantee every student will speak to the whole group.

Model a reason without making one choice sound better. For example: “I would choose the star-patterned socks because I like drawing stars.” A different student might choose the cloud hat because they enjoy unusual shapes. Neither needs to own those items.

In pairs, one person can respond while the other listens, then switch. A listener can ask one neutral follow-up such as “What detail would you add?” Avoid turning the exchange into a debate about why the other person’s preference is wrong.

I would choose ___ because ___. One detail I imagine is ___. I can see why someone might choose the other option because ___.

Use only the first sentence if the full starter is too much for the task. A student can also point to a written option, draw an idea or choose not to explain.

Make room for different answers

Some questions use words such as emblem, motto or pennant. Explain unfamiliar terms before asking for a choice, using a simple drawing or example. Skip a question that depends on vocabulary the class has not met.

For a simpler format, draw the two options and let students point to one. For a longer writing task, ask for a reason and one specific detail. Students can change their answer after hearing an idea; the first choice does not need to become a label.

Keep it a conversationDo not rank students by how quickly they answer, how many choices match the group or whether their clothes fit a theme. Listening and passing are ordinary options.

If the organizer wants to choose actual themes, start a separate process with approved options and clear rules. The theme-voting guide covers that task. Do not quietly convert a casual classroom discussion into an official vote.

Save a small question pack

Download the editable question pack

The pack contains the 20 questions in the same four groups, followed by reader notes and the sentence starter. It is plain text for copying, editing or printing, rather than a fixed-size card PDF. Preview the layout if printing for students.

Keep a few selected questions with the class plan for a future discussion. If leaving the activity for another teacher, record the chosen questions, response format and stopping point in the substitute handoff. The inclusive planning guide has more ways to offer different forms of participation.

Find a theme to talk about

Explore ideas before planning the school’s confirmed week.